Fics like One Trick Four Treats!

All Hallows Eve is almost over, and Nick Holiday has given out all his candy, but three more adorable little girls have come knocking, looking for a very special treat!

You may also like

1. Ellie's Slutty Birthday by itsagarbagecan (Original Work)
2. Happy Birthday, Baby (Original Work)
3. April's First! by Mr_Macguffin (Original Work)
4. Daddy's Day! by Mr_Macguffin (Original Work)
5. All Things Fair and Bright are Thine by allyoops (Original Work)
6. Fatherly Assistance by WestOrEast (Original Work)
7. How Accidents Happen by ItsNeverSafe (Original Work)
8. Breed Baby Breed (No Fandom, Original Work)
9. Lipa's Flower by Rgbage (Original Work)
10. A day in the life of a father of a slut by JM_Writes (Original Work)
11. A hot summer night by Burning_feeniks (Original Work)
12. The Gift that keeps on Giving! by Mr_Macguffin (Original Work)
13. Raising Her Right (Original Work)
14. joy ride (Original Work)
15. Dealing With Assassins by ALewdInvention (Original Work)
16. That's Not Nougat I'm Filled With: A Halloween Night of Filth by orphan_account (Original Work)
17. The Safety Word by Kinjite (Original Work)
18. X-MAS - Seed of Santa by YoungFoxHunter (Original Work)
19. Seeding Stellar Bodies by Mr_Macguffin (Original Work)
20. just like mom by Ari_likesPeaches (Original Work)