Fics like Finders Keepers

Aaron Olsen is an ordinary guy, or as ordinary as someone can be when your parents are rich. His only friends are Zoey Kazanova and Carol Lewis, two of the most beautiful girls in his high school. Although he has his fantasies (as any teenage boy would in his situation), he knows it will never happen for real. So, when they invite him over to Carol's place while everyone's parents are away and will be mostly unsupervised, he knows it's perfectly innocent. There's no way the offer to study for a book report together was just a pretext for seducing him with a threeway. Right?

You may also like

1. The Babysitter by Mr_MINUS32 (Original Work)
2. Boss Lady by sanguia (Original Work)
3. Bittersweet Thing by sweetandsure (Original Work)
4. Betrayed (Original Work)
5. Anchor Stitch by sweetandsure (Original Work)
6. Samantha's New Life: The Weirdness of a Mother's Love by GroundRDP (Original Work)
7. Dog-Girl Academy: Otherwise Known As Bitches Galore! (x Male Reader) by BigBustyBnuuy (Original Work, Furry (Fandom))
8. American Bee-auty by AlfieHunter (Original Work)
9. Mean Girl(s) by shadowtempt (Original Work)
10. Taboos by inklover (Original Work)
11. Shark-Girl Streamer Has an Insatiable Fetish for Human Cock! (x Male Reader) by BigBustyBnuuy (Original Work)
12. Again by Silver_Shroud (Original Work)
13. Erica & Yannis by AlfieHunter (Original Work)
14. Turning the Tables by rebooting (Original Work)
15. Fuck You by AgathaRioLover69, Anonymous88 (Original Work, No Fandom)
16. Lost and Found by NotForTheFaint (Original Work)
17. Here Be (Horny) Dragons by ColdLuigi (Original Work)
18. Live to Serve by Thirst4Chicken (Original Work)
19. The Anniversary by theway (Original Work)
20. Marriage Is Hard Work by especiallyheinous6 (Original Work)