Fics like 'Cause I'm Supreme (Choose Me)

Waverly has everyone wrapped around her little finger, but Nicole still knows she's the King (... or Queen) of her heart

You may also like

1. Memories that Remain by HaughtBreaker, jaybear1701 (Wynonna Earp (TV))
2. 2022 Pride Writing Challenge by Ncredible (Wynonna Earp (TV), Supergirl (TV 2015), more)
3. When Two Worlds Collide by Sharpe_Lance (DC's Legends of Tomorrow (TV), Wynonna Earp (TV), more)
4. too much by brogurt (Wynonna Earp (TV))
5. Blind Devotion by ShaunaDZ (Wynonna Earp (TV))
6. Unexpected by ShaunaDZ (Wynonna Earp (TV))
7. Strangers Again by Last_Young_Renegade (Wynonna Earp (TV))
8. Stop Making Eyes At Me (But I Don't Really Want You To) by Half, TheGaySmurf (Wynonna Earp (TV))
9. Girls Are Like Guns by bootsncatz (Wynonna Earp (TV))
10. Fairies & Forevers by outsidemynorm15 (Wynonna Earp (TV))
11. Nothing Compares by wrackwonder (Wynonna Earp (TV))
12. find a home, lonely heart by tigerlo (Wynonna Earp (TV))
13. The Choice by s_the_red, sarahqwilson (Wynonna Earp (TV))
14. The Red Mane by Asteroth (Wynonna Earp (TV))
15. Scars of Sweet Paradise by wrackwonder (Wynonna Earp (TV))
16. The Things Life Throws at Us. by bootsncatz, thegaynerd (Wynonna Earp (TV))
17. An Otherwise Disappointing Life by brunetteandblond (Wynonna Earp (TV))
18. Take Me As You Please by Last_Young_Renegade (Wynonna Earp (TV))
19. let me down slow by isawet (Wynonna Earp (TV))
20. Little White Lies by Trufreak89 (Wynonna Earp (TV))