Fics like god i wish that you had thought this through (before i went and fell in love with you)

Ray and Heather navigate their feelings and wants in the aftermath of the Panic summer. Even Icarus fell eventually. Title from Olivia Rodrigo's 'traitor'

You may also like

1. (The things I did) Just so I could call you mine by Jilyfirecracker (Panic (TV 2021))
2. Dancing with the Fireflies by Poptart318 (Panic (TV 2021))
3. favorite crime by punkybookster (Panic (TV 2021))
4. Into The Fire by anniebibananie (Panic (TV 2021))
5. In the darkest of places is you by nightshenanigans (Panic (TV 2021))
6. three words by sheriffandsteel (Panic (TV 2021))
7. it's not the leaving that's hard (it's the staying away) by lottielotsof (Panic (TV 2021))
8. skyscraper hands & soaring hearts by heartscape (Panic (TV 2021))
9. Trash by punkybookster (Panic (TV 2021))
10. The Way the Night Moves (It Makes Me Think of You) by JackEPeace (Panic (TV 2021))
11. don't feed the vultures by youcarrymeaway (Panic (TV 2021))
12. amazon original series short prompts by Samjr04 (The Summer I Turned Pretty (TV 2022), Just Add Magic (TV), more)
13. Takes One To Know One - Dodge Mason x Reader by suddenly_simon (Panic (TV 2021))
14. Love Is Patient, Love Is Kind by Poptart318 (Panic (TV 2021))
15. i don't know why all the trees change in the fall (but i know you're not scared of anything at all) by theboldeststrokeyoucanmake (Panic (TV 2021))
16. Insatiable by Ohhnicks (Panic (TV 2021))
17. Apples and Trees by punkybookster (Panic (TV 2021))
18. Let Me In Your Ocean by Ohhnicks (Panic (TV 2021))
19. i wish i could leave you my love by anniebibananie (Panic (TV 2021), Panic (TV))
20. worship by al3xpdx (Challengers (Movie 2024), Panic (TV 2021))