Fics like Not What It Seems

Ethan has been acting weird and Sarah and Benny suspect a love spell. Only, Ethan is being super flirty with Benny, so either the witch who cast the spell messed up, or it’s not a love spell. (Dubious consent because spelled Ethan pins Benny to a locker but nothing happens, just put it there in case)

You may also like

  1. a hundred things i can't believe by halfwheeze (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  2. Piecewise Equations & The Inner Turmoil of a Mathlete by PixiePaint (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  3. can i trust in you? (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  4. do you feel the same? by katsuk1 (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  5. Lean Back & Breathe by NotALemon (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  6. Cuddles and Kisses by Calacious (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  7. That Old Black Magic by csi_sanders1129 (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  8. kiss me like i'm your first choice by PixiePaint (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  9. Spellbound: The Curse of the Lucifractor by Dxlilith (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  10. Body Language by csi_sanders1129 (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  11. cut the headlights, summer's a knife by sourcandyroll (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  12. Magic Led Me To You by Pa_tr0_clus (My Babysitter's A Vampire, Disney - All Media Types)
  13. Drowning by csi_sanders1129 (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  14. Split by 9LWrites (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  15. Have a Little Confidence by MarsInsane (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  16. Soul Thread by KuroNekoFe (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  17. Nothing Like The Supernatural To Put Us Back Together by ahale (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  18. mary's song (oh my my my) (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  19. 4 Times Benny and Ethan were Discovered to be Dating and 1 Time it was Intentional by orphan_account (My Babysitter's A Vampire)
  20. Right, Round, Round, Round by mrsvc (My Babysitter's A Vampire)