Fics like Pantomime

At Tubb's request, Jenny and Cassie go undercover as a lesbian couple to draw out a killer. Filled with fake dating tropes, sexual tension, smut, and our ladies being unreasonably hot and bothered.

You may also like

1. Fourth of July by kissthigh (Big Sky (US TV))
2. Heaven Sent by morganaDW (Supernatural (TV 2005), Big Sky (US TV))
3. Drinking in the Multiverse by jublke (Supernatural (TV 2005), Big Sky (US TV), more)
4. sex is good (but have you tried) by Levana_x (Big Sky (US TV))
5. Jensen Ackles Character Headcanons by Team_Ackles (Supernatural (TV 2005), Tracker (TV 2024), more)
6. Good Girl by kissthigh (Big Sky (US TV))
7. Moving On by Magnetism_bind (Big Sky (US TV))
8. Older by dibelladonna (Big Sky (US TV), Supernatural (TV 2005))
9. Vices by writethelifeyouwant (Supernatural (TV 2005), Big Sky (US TV))
10. Callin' Him by kissthigh (Big Sky (US TV))
11. After Hours by smolandgrumpy (Supernatural (TV 2005), Big Sky (US TV))
12. Camping Confessions by kissthigh (Big Sky (US TV))
13. Hide and Seek by kissthigh (Big Sky (US TV))
14. Summer Cabin by kissthigh (Big Sky (US TV))
15. ABC original shows short prompts by Samjr04 (The Rookie (TV 2018), 9-1-1 (TV), more)
16. The Triplets by WellDoneBeca (The Boys (TV 2019), Supernatural (TV 2005), more)
17. big skies and blue eyes by TessAlyn (Big Sky (US TV), Bridgewater (Podcast))
18. Flipped Switch by klutzy_girl (Big Sky (US TV))
19. Monthly Series by my_very_own_fanfiction (Ghostbusters - All Media Types, Blues Brothers (Movies), more)
20. Babysittin' by kissthigh (Big Sky (US TV))