Fics like First Time for Everything

Nick has always flirted with Elena despite her relationship with Clay. Clay finds an opportunity for payback in Nick's relationship with Vanessa. Vanessa gets to explore with Clay and Elena. Elena finally has a little fun with Nick.

You may also like

  1. BETWEEN DUSK AND BONE by bewitchedfaeyrie (Bitten (TV), Women of the Otherworld - Kelley Armstrong)
  2. Run with the Wolf by Splintercat (Stranger Things (TV 2016), Women of the Otherworld - Kelley Armstrong, more)
  3. Rabid Plotbunny Quarantine Centre by TheCatsTales (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, Women of the Otherworld - Kelley Armstrong, more)
  4. Everyone Knows (Women of the Otherworld - Kelley Armstrong, Bitten (TV))
  5. the spine of your body by torigates (Women of the Otherworld - Kelley Armstrong)
  6. Consequences by evrymeeveryyou (Women of the Otherworld - Kelley Armstrong)
  7. That Time of the Month by orphan_account (Women of the Otherworld - Kelley Armstrong)
  8. Virgin by orphan_account (Women of the Otherworld - Kelley Armstrong, Bitten (TV))
  9. Wolfish Tendencies by hariboo (Women of the Otherworld - Kelley Armstrong)
  10. my child arrived by torigates (Women of the Otherworld - Kelley Armstrong)
  11. Stairs (Women of the Otherworld - Kelley Armstrong, Bitten (TV))
  12. Malcolm by Splintercat (Women of the Otherworld - Kelley Armstrong)
  13. Haunting at 30,000 Feet by anticyclone (Women of the Otherworld - Kelley Armstrong)
  14. Mistletoe Magic by angelan (Women of the Otherworld - Kelley Armstrong)
  15. Slayer Twice Bitten by Holly_Pocket (Buffy the Vampire Slayer (TV), Bitten (TV), more)
  16. Tasks by orphan_account (Women of the Otherworld - Kelley Armstrong, Bitten (TV))
  17. Locating by anticyclone (Women of the Otherworld - Kelley Armstrong)
  18. Avoid Hormonal Pregnant Werewolves by orphan_account (Women of the Otherworld - Kelley Armstrong)
  19. self defense by torigates (Women of the Otherworld - Kelley Armstrong)
  20. Level of Dress by orphan_account (Bitten - Kelley Armstrong, Women of the Otherworld - Kelley Armstrong, more)