Fics like Now, Then, and Again

Andy and Neal are together in three different lifetimes.

You may also like

1. Ready Now (If You Can Wait a Little More) by samanthahirr (American Idol RPF, Adam Lambert (Musician), more)
2. The Symbol of a Song by hopefulwriter27 (Supernatural, American Idol RPF)
3. Future Legend by winterlive (American Idol RPF)
4. through the storm we reach the shore by stickmarionette (American Idol RPF, Kris Allen (Musician))
5. Of Reddest Stolen Cherries by Words_instead (American Idol RPF)
6. Making The Band by like-i-love-you (American Idol RPF, Midwest Kings)
7. (This Is) Not a Statement by seperis (American Idol RPF, Adam Lambert (Musician), more)
8. All or Nothing [2nd Edition] by Krysnel_Nicavis (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, Adam Lambert (Musician), more)
9. God is a Gambler, the Universe His Casino by CydSA (American Idol RPF, Fringe)
10. Outlaw's Prayer by honestys_easy (Music RPF, Real Person Fiction, more)
11. Cat and Mouse by janescott, jeck (Adam Lambert - Fandom, American Idol RPF, more)
12. Zombies Ate Your Idols (They Were Delicious) by Solarcat (My Chemical Romance, American Idol RPF)
13. After David by like-i-love-you (American Idol RPF, Midwest Kings)
14. Just One Sheep by Camden (American Idol RPF)
15. Drabbles From Before by rositamia (Popslash, X-Men (Movieverse), more)
16. Money Can Buy You Love. And Glitter by CamilleCarelli (Adam Lambert (Musician), American Idol RPF, more)
17. Post Lambert, Ergo Propter Lambert by Roga (The West Wing, American Idol RPF)
18. A Subtle Fire by Butterfly (American Idol RPF)
19. The Last Guardians by CydSA (American Idol RPF, Supernatural RPF)
20. Always The Best Friend by jeyhawk (American Idol RPF)