Fics like The First Four Years

The prom theme has something to do with Paris. If Paris were a high school gym with a cover band.

You may also like

1. Almost Perfect, Almost Yours by Geeky_Mind (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, Smallville, more)
2. Elsewhere... by WinchesterNimrod (Batman - All Media Types, Batman (Comics), more)
3. Detainment by DragonflyxParodies (The Batman (Movie 2022), Batman - All Media Types, more)
4. The Mysterious Case of the Pink Kryptonite by Nicnac (Smallville)
5. Going To Plan by Gaia (Superman (Movie 2025), Smallville, more)
6. Moving On by astolat (Smallville, Justice League)
7. Play Forgiveness by museaway (Smallville)
8. even as a shadow by ForgottenFrog (Smallville, Superman - All Media Types)
9. Scars Are Souvenirs You Never Lose by saudades_girl (Smallville, Superman - All Media Types)
10. "No Offense, But Why Were We Friends?" by josephina_x (Smallville, Smallville Season 11 (Comics))
11. When it all comes down by Elenduen (The Avengers (Marvel Movies), The Avengers (Marvel) - All Media Types, more)
12. Never Get To Heaven by Elenduen (The Avengers (Marvel Movies), Smallville, more)
13. The War of House El by Alzirf (Superman - All Media Types, Superman (Movie 2025), more)
14. Le Dormeur du Val by Pun (Smallville)
15. Long Time Coming by BewareTheIdes15 (Smallville, Superman - All Media Types)
16. Vacation by astolat (Smallville, Superman (Comics), more)
17. Reasons by Elenduen (The Avengers (Marvel) - All Media Types, Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice, more)
18. Of Comic Books and Doublethink by Nicnac (Smallville)
19. Can We Start Again? by Rosawyn (Smallville, Man of Steel (2013), more)
20. Little Owlet by TheWitchBoy (White Collar (TV 2009), Smallville, more)