Fics like sobriety & apple pie & religion, oh my!

When Sam answers his door, he expects one of his friends, or one of Jess's friends, or maybe even Jess herself (sometimes she locks herself out). He is not expecting his older brother, and he is definitely not expecting a version of his older brother from 16 years into the future.

You may also like

1. Feast of the Assumptions by Amazonia_8 (Supernatural)
2. Excite by perpetuallycaffeinated (Supernatural)
3. When the World Screams by K_K_TiBal (Supernatural)
4. Tempest of Oblivion by thepinupchemist (Supernatural)
5. Christmas in July by followyourenergy (Supernatural)
6. Knight Takes King by darkforetold (Supernatural)
7. Hunting Husbands by bendingsignpost (Supernatural)
8. I Like You (Like Me) by Carmexgirl (Supernatural)
9. When You Say Nothing at All by TrenchcoatBaby (Supernatural)
10. The Apple Of My Eye by noangelsinthegarrison (Supernatural)
11. a world above water by museaway (Supernatural)
12. Face to Face with the Skies by quiddative (Supernatural)
13. I Will Always Love You by WhiskyBoys (Supernatural)
14. As You Will by kototyph (Supernatural)
15. quickie by saltyfeathers (Supernatural)
16. The Talking Room by todisturbtheuniverse (Supernatural)
17. You Light The Spark (In My Bonfire Heart) by noangelsinthegarrison (Supernatural)
18. The Truth by whelvenwings (Supernatural)
19. Meet Cute by GatesKeeper (Supernatural)
20. The Care and Handling of Angels by fanfic814 (Supernatural)