Fics like Underneath

Not even Melissa knows the real Faye.

You may also like

1. Tension by Aaronlisa (Secret Circle (TV))
2. Misery Poker by Kithri (Secret Circle (TV), Vampire Diaries (TV))
3. got a scar where all my urges bled by lullabelle (Secret Circle (TV))
4. Here Be Monsters by Tenshinrtaiga (Vampire Diaries (TV), Secret Circle (TV))
5. The Making of Monsters by Tenshinrtaiga (Vampire Diaries (TV), Secret Circle (TV))
6. Great Minds by Helix (Secret Circle (TV))
7. The Original Big Bad by ReveredTheophania (Vampire Diaries (TV), teen wolf - Fandom, more)
8. the world's a better place when it's upside down by TheFifthCircuit (Secret Circle (TV))
9. The 66th Annual Hunger Games by thiccwhale (Merlin (TV), Supernatural, more)
10. the prices we pay by dreamsleep (Secret Circle (TV), Vampire Diaries (TV))
11. Strangers by MeBatty (Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Walking Dead (TV), more)
12. Ten Million Fireflies by clover71 (Secret Circle (TV))
13. 5 Times Someone Found Out, The 1 Time They Didn't by Sugarbubbleslove (Secret Circle (TV))
14. How Do You Know? by GrayOwl (Secret Circle (TV))
15. Heaven and Hell by thiccwhale (Merlin (TV), Supernatural, more)
16. Becoming Alpha by KinggLovee (Secret Circle (TV), Teen Wolf (TV))
17. Die By The Drop by Dodger (Secret Circle (TV))
18. Proximity by Orokiah (Secret Circle (TV))