Fics like Have a cup of cheer

When Natasha took the time to look you up and down, frown with her eyes like you were lacking in some way, and then said “Down Under Coffee on Thursday at 6 pm. He’ll be wearing a festive red sweater with a reindeer. Withhold judgement until you meet him” you went to Down Under Coffee for 6 on Thursday and you looked for someone in a reindeer sweater.

You may also like

Professional Pride by galwednesday (Captain America (Movies))
on the catwalk by biblionerd07 (Captain America (Movies))
centrifugal motion (perpetual bliss) by obsessivereader (Captain America (Movies), Marvel Cinematic Universe)
Apartment 409 by 74days (Captain America (Movies))
It's a bittersweet ending (if you know what I mean) by relenafanel (Captain America (Movies))
Slip of the Tongue by leveragehunters (Captain America (Movies))
new traditions by bornes (Marvel Cinematic Universe, Captain America (Movies))
res novae by chaosy (Marvel Cinematic Universe, Captain America (Movies))
Rudeness Will Not Be Tolerated In This Starbucks by camwolfe (Marvel Cinematic Universe, Captain America (Movies))
I think I'm in love by sweetjellies (Captain America (Movies))
lights at two dollars a strand by legete (Captain America (Movies), The Avengers (Marvel Movies), more)
Leave Those Umbrellas At Home by rohkeutta (Captain America (Movies))
One Does Not Simply Walk Into JoAnn Fabrics (And other millennial lessons from The Winter Soldier) by attackofthezee (Captain America (Movies))
whose arms will hold you by biblionerd07 (Captain America (Movies))
(I Can't Let This Go) I'm On My Way by kototyph (Captain America (Movies), Marvel Cinematic Universe)
Cafe Au Écoute by littlesystems (Captain America (Movies))
and we'll get married under the shining sun by radialarch (Captain America (Movies))
A History of Birds by OddityBoddity (Captain America (Movies))
A Silver Thread In The Darkness by 74days (Captain America (Movies))
Cute Stitch Witch Discount by attackofthezee (Captain America (Movies))