Fics like A Halloween Treat

Sarah and Nancy go on a trip together one Halloween's eve. Just the two of them, alone in a cabin while they're friends vacation out where. What are two young witches to do besides make some magic ?

You may also like

1. Afterlife Protocol by bubbles19 (The Vampire Diaries (TV), The Originals (TV))
2. Familia Supra Omnia by IAMiniquity (The Vampire Diaries & Related Fandoms, The Originals (TV), more)
3. Where the Future Came to Die by Stealing_Fire_67 (Legacies (TV 2018), The Originals (TV), more)
4. Big O Notation by orphan_account (Scream (Movies))
5. Make Me Bleed While My Heart is Still Beating by cemeterywifey (Scream (Movies))
6. a thousand times (we tempted fate) by orphan_account (The Craft (1996))
7. Hades by NeckingMyself (Scream (Movies), Scream (TV))
8. stoned by 3amWrites (Scream (Movies))
9. when you scream, it drives me nuts (if you hang up, i'll spill your guts) by orphan_account (Scream (Movies))
10. love evolves into unknowns by pussyandautism (Scream (Movies), Scream 5 - Fandom)
11. When the Moon reaches its Apex by ThatDeadGorl (The Vampire Diaries (TV))
12. Lightning Flowers by thornswithroses (The Craft (1996))
13. LIVING IN THE RED. by CaseyDixon1 (Scream (Movies), Criminal Minds (US TV), more)
14. What's Your Favorite Scary Movie? by ghostfacemykingILY (Scream (Movies), Parahumans Series - Wildbow)
15. a wicked game by woelune (A Good Girl's Guide to Murder (TV 2024), Scream (Movies))
16. Little Freak by cheektocheekinhell (Scream (Movies))
17. Show Me How You Bleed by SerpentCountess (Scream (Movies))
18. Shadow in the Starlight by Geeky_Mind (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, The Vampire Diaries (TV), more)
19. Baby It’s Cold Outside by VisionsInCrimson (The Vampire Diaries (TV))
20. She Deserves Better by CrazyGirl92 (The Vampire Diaries & Related Fandoms, The Vampire Diaries (TV), more)