Fics like Super Mario Replay

Edit 2/21/2022: Recommended as an AO3 classic work for Fanworks Day 2022! Description: Peach never thought she'd have issues if she picked between the two rivals for her affection. But she did, and problems start spiraling out of her control. Old enemies return and foes beyond her craziest imagination start to appear. Or: Peach picks Mario. Bowser throws a world class tantrum that may or may not include resurrecting dead villains and recruiting them as his minions. His plan might also extend to a certain world where everything is paper. Joke originally in tags: “Uh…. can I get a… “Screek,” a “localization team out to lunch,” two things of “DESTROY,” an “Ursula fangirl,” an “extraterrestrial flower simp,” “a spectacularly bad art collector,” “Santa Claus’ arms dealer,” and a “Nice Guy with an army?” Added in Chapter 6: “This time, can I have another “Nice Guy,” a “poetry clown,” a “reduced to kickball status,” and “emo Peach?” Chapter 50+: “I’d like to return everyone except...”

You may also like

  1. One does not simply become a crime lord... BY ACCIDENT! by SaltyOni666 (Miraculous Ladybug, Nefarious (Video Game), more)
  2. Gathering the Audience by UnderEarthFilms (RWBY, Re:ゼロから始める異世界生活 | Re:Zero Starting Life in Another World (Anime), more)
  3. Moleman's Epic Rap Battles by Moleman9000 (Multi-Fandom, Epic Rap Battles of History, more)
  4. 31 days of ruining Overhaul’s day by Rocboi135 (僕のヒーローアカデミア | Boku no Hero Academia | My Hero Academia (Anime & Manga), Super Mario & Related Fandoms, more)
  5. Eternally Never Yours by EternallyEcho (Super Mario & Related Fandoms, Super Mario Bros., more)
  6. Earth's Strange History or How Man Conquered the Stars [OLD] by Newbie1221 (Doctor Who & Related Fandoms, Stargate - All Media Types, more)
  7. Marriage Law Rejection Letters by sakura_lisel (Harry Potter - Fandom, One Piece, more)
  8. The Hero of the Mushroom Kingdom by Braii_AK (僕のヒーローアカデミア | Boku no Hero Academia | My Hero Academia (Anime & Manga), Super Mario Bros. (Video Games))
  9. The Baddest of the Badlands by supermollio (Super Mario Bros. (Video Games), Super Mario & Related Fandoms, more)
  10. Breaking Through the Core by PookaDragon (The Super Mario Movies (Illumination Movies), Super Mario Bros. (Video Games), more)
  11. Olimar's Alimony by Already_in_Use, TheCrimsonSquid (Super Smash Brothers, Pikmin (Video Game), more)
  12. A-Z Female Collection by Jrobbo117 (RWBY, 僕のヒーローアカデミア | Boku no Hero Academia | My Hero Academia (Anime & Manga), more)
  13. Koopa Rockers in the House Tonight by Liquified (The Super Mario Bros. Movie (2023), Super Mario Bros. (Video Games), more)
  14. Soul Bound by LadyWitchBlade (The Super Mario Bros. Movie (2023), Super Mario Bros. (Video Games), more)
  15. Danganronpa V89 - Eye of the Beholder by Pokeaven (Dangan Ronpa Series, Dangan Ronpa: Trigger Happy Havoc, more)
  16. Trapped in Silk by SinTheSkunk (Super Mario & Related Fandoms, New Super Mario Bros. (Video Games), more)
  17. A Maid's Worst Nightmare by spikedsoul (Super Mario & Related Fandoms)
  18. Brothers in Arms (A.K.A. Smashers and Dragons) by MeluiethBox (Super Smash Brothers, Dungeons & Dragons - All Media Types, more)
  19. No Plumbers Allowed by NullenVoid (Parahumans Series - Wildbow, Super Mario & Related Fandoms, more)
  20. .:Same Man I Was Before:. by DarkwingSnark (Super Mario & Related Fandoms, Super Mario Bros. (Video Games))