Fics like and you smiled, because you knew.

Joe is an incurable romantic. Nicky doesn't really believe in an institution that promises only what he already has. Or: Five times Joe proposed to Nicky and one time he didn't.

You may also like

  1. Three Immortals and a Puppy Walk Into a Bar by Survivah (The Old Guard (Movie 2020))
  2. say the word (& I'll be your renaissance man) by liadan14 (The Old Guard (Movie 2020))
  3. watch me beg to never let you go by BeesKnees (The Old Guard (Movie 2020))
  4. the person falling here is me by storm_petrel (The Old Guard (Movie 2020))
  5. fearfully and wonderfully made by orphan_account (The Old Guard (Movie 2020))
  6. The Two Sides of Forever by CypressSunn (The Old Guard (Movie 2020))
  7. offer no absolutes by liadan14 (The Old Guard (Movie 2020))
  8. The #ImmortalHusbands Conspiracy by Amiril, phoenixacid (The Old Guard (Movie 2020))
  9. campus cryptid vs. future valedictorian by GlassRose (The Old Guard (Movie 2020))
  10. Half In Love with Easeful Death by merle_p (The Old Guard (Movie 2020))
  11. Le Vite by ScribeofArda (The Old Guard (Movie 2020))
  12. Lines in the Sand by goldheartedsky (The Old Guard (Movie 2020))
  13. (don't) blame it on the moonlight by liadan14 (The Old Guard (Movie 2020))
  14. Sing Me Like a Choir by orphan_account (The Old Guard (Movie 2020))
  15. command me to be well (The Old Guard (Movie 2020))
  16. Frost and Fjords by Arkada (The Old Guard (Movie 2020))
  17. Exit Strategies by CypressSunn (The Old Guard (Movie 2020))
  18. The most epic bedtime story ever told by TheLoveliestCrime (The Old Guard (Movie 2020))
  19. everywhere on earth you go (you're gonna have me) by nondz (The Old Guard (Movie 2020))
  20. A Conspiracy of Idiots by Sixthlight (The Old Guard (Movie 2020))