Fics like Candyholics Never Made Good Heroes Anyways

It’s a year later, junior year at Stanford University, and Sam—at Balthazar’s constant insistence—somehow manages to convince Castiel to go to his cousin’s Halloween party. However, he doesn’t expect his boyfriend to be so… into the idea of dressing up.

You may also like

1. Cursed Blessings by jsymo (Supernatural)
2. Comfortable by kototyph (Supernatural)
3. Spaghetti Revelations by Zetal (Supernatural)
4. Rise and Shine by coffeeandcas (Supernatural)
5. Through Heaven's Eyes by Lies_Unfurl (Supernatural)
6. Definition by domesticadventures (Supernatural)
7. Distance Means Nothing (When Someone Means Everything) by GhostGarrison (Supernatural)
8. Run Right; or Lie by orphan_account (Supernatural)
9. Here We Still Remain by vailkagami (Supernatural)
10. Closer to Heaven and Closer to You by Epiphanyx7 (Supernatural)
11. Through the Glass, Darkly by The_Bookkeeper (Supernatural)
12. Everyone Needs Something by AnOddSock (Supernatural)
13. How many slams in an old screen door? by dandelioness (Supernatural)
14. Two One-Act Plays by The_Bookkeeper (Supernatural)
15. What Comes Next by posingasme (Supernatural)
16. Shelter by Fallynleaf (Supernatural)
17. A More Profound Bond by confxsed (Supernatural)
18. Household of Three by idiotbrothers (Supernatural)
19. Tender by GildedBird (Supernatural)
20. This Grace of Love is Mine Eye by orphan_account (Supernatural)