Fics like The Morning Star

"Oh, Father." A voice whispered brokenly from deep inside the cave in the earth. "I'm so sorry." When Lucifer shows repentance in the cage, God gives him a choice. Stay in the cage, or be reincarnated as a human. "Who the hell are you?" Dean asked. "I'm Lucifer," Harry replied. "Who did you think I was, Michael in a tutu?"

You may also like

1. Hunting Husbands by bendingsignpost (Supernatural)
2. Arrangements by icarus_chained (Good Omens - Neil Gaiman & Terry Pratchett, Supernatural, more)
3. Love Bites by MalMuses (Supernatural)
4. Critical Mass by ireallyhatecornnuts (Supernatural)
5. aka. Dean Campbell by Valinde (Supernatural)
6. Never Have I Ever by sweetdean (Supernatural)
7. Waves by wormstaches (Supernatural)
8. Gravity vs Velocity by PaperAnn (Supernatural)
9. Nine to Five by narrativeimperative (Supernatural)
10. Our Old Heroes by AdelaClancy (Supernatural)
11. Artfully Crafted Words of Poetry by starsinursa (Supernatural)
12. A Judicious Application of Free Will by Annie%20D (Supernatural)
13. An Accidental Incubus by jupiter_james (Supernatural)
14. Through The Fire by ThursdaysWaywardWriter, saltnhalo (Supernatural)
15. Ergative/Absolutive by glassedplanets (Supernatural)
16. The Parts of Our Sum by Annie%20D (Supernatural)
17. Along My Restless Palms by Sass_Master (Supernatural)
18. Plot Holes by saltyfeathers (Supernatural)
19. Inevitable Homoeroticism in Spanish Romantic Heroes by prosopopeya (Supernatural)
20. Jump the Track by alysian_fields (Supernatural)