Fics like Is THIS Your Card?

Tugger didn't think he'd be spending a perfectly good Saturday at a kid's birthday party, and neither did he expect the hired magician to be so alluring and mystifying.

You may also like

1. Jellicle Chats for Jellicle Cats by Sillybubs (Cats - Andrew Lloyd Webber, Old Possum's Book of Practical Cats - T. S. Eliot, more)
2. Warm by Kalira (Cats - Andrew Lloyd Webber, Cats (1998))
3. Kind Of Mates by infandomswetrust (Cats - Andrew Lloyd Webber, Old Possum's Book of Practical Cats - T. S. Eliot)
4. Caught Out by Kalira (Cats - Andrew Lloyd Webber, Cats (1998))
5. To Catch A Tugger (Cats - Andrew Lloyd Webber)
6. Gold Rush by millenari (Cats - Andrew Lloyd Webber, Cats (1998))
7. The Naming of Cats: Cats (2019) vs. Cats: The Musical, Explained by iodhadh (Cats - Andrew Lloyd Webber, Cats (2019))
8. Isolation by Kalira (Cats - Andrew Lloyd Webber, Cats (1998))
9. Fragile Heart by Griddlebone (Cats - Andrew Lloyd Webber)
10. Baby, It's Cold Outside by corruptedteacups (Cats - Andrew Lloyd Webber)
11. pee stuff by backstagecats (Cats - Andrew Lloyd Webber)
12. The (Little) Man in Black by millenari (Cats - Andrew Lloyd Webber, Cats (1998))
13. He's Not, He's Not, She's Not by Chef_Geekier (Cats - Andrew Lloyd Webber)
14. Clever Cat by mirokai (Cats - Andrew Lloyd Webber, Cats (1998))
15. Mr. Vague and Aloof and his Terrible Bore by hearth_goddess (Cats - Andrew Lloyd Webber)
16. Catalyst by OnTheFritz (Cats - Andrew Lloyd Webber, Old Possum's Book of Practical Cats - T. S. Eliot, more)
17. Cat's Cradle (Cats - Andrew Lloyd Webber)
18. Stranger by lynndyre (Cats - Andrew Lloyd Webber)
19. leading and following, faster and slower by orphan_account (Cats - Andrew Lloyd Webber, Cats (1998), more)
20. Cats NSFW sketches by yoah (Cats - Andrew Lloyd Webber, Cats (1998), more)