Fics like It's Not You

College soulmate au where the last name of your soulmate is tatooed on your arm since birth. Castiel Novak has the word "Winchester" on his wrist. He goes to college and meets his roommate, Sam, who has the word "Novak" on his wrist. They don't feel anything towards each other and think it must be a mistake. That is, until they meet the others' brother.

You may also like

1. White Russian by vipjuly (Supernatural)
2. A Fish Called Castiel by fairychangeling (Supernatural)
3. Cynophobia by destieljunkie (Supernatural)
4. I Wanna Get Outside (Of Me) by emwebb17 (Supernatural)
5. Gravity vs Velocity by PaperAnn (Supernatural)
6. May Sunbeams Find You by LittleAngelCassie (Supernatural)
7. Fighting Chance by vamprav (Supernatural)
8. Hunting Husbands by bendingsignpost (Supernatural)
9. SPN Watching the Show by Mickey_Todoroki (Supernatural, Supernatural (TV 2005))
10. It's The End of the World (As We Know It) by tiamatv (Supernatural)
11. By the Dark of the Moon by r2metoo (Supernatural)
12. A Story for Every Corner by thepinupchemist (Supernatural)
13. Angel Blessings by LittleAngelCassie (Supernatural)
14. It Takes a Nest by SailorChibi (Supernatural)
15. A Fish Out of Water by MalMuses (Supernatural)
16. Black Swans by Wolfling, omphalos (Supernatural)
17. I'll Be Good by LittleAngelCassie (Supernatural)
18. Living Broken Adjacent by LittleAngelCassie (Supernatural)
19. Dean Winchester and the Goddamn Kill-Steal by bendingsignpost (Supernatural)
20. Hark! The Herald Angels Sing by Astrophilla, sunshinewinchesters (Supernatural)