Fics like Breaking Character

Not everybody buys that Karmy "got back together" after the whole threesome fiasco. Shane convinces the two fake girlfriends to step up their acting game if they want to convince the school they're really together. It becomes a bit of a competition for them. And Amy is winning. And Karma's not sure if it's a game any more.

You may also like

1. Lesbian SMUT One Shots by AWriterWhoJustExists (Twilight Series - Stephenie Meyer, Wednesday (TV 2022), more)
2. Your Song by Anoel (Carol (2015), Glee, more)
3. the rest of the world was black and white (but we were in screaming color) by forbiddenquill (Faking It (TV 2014))
4. she might've let you hold her hand in school (but i'mma show you how to graduate) by singsongsung (Faking It (TV 2014))
5. delayed gratification by twistedsky (Faking It (TV 2014))
6. Fooled Around and Fell in Love by Secretmonkey (Faking It (TV 2014))
7. Underage One Shot Requests [Currently Open] by aft33 (Teen Wolf (TV), Pretty Little Liars, more)
8. Stop Pretending by forbiddenquill (Faking It (TV 2014))
9. only one cure for this body of mine by tamaraface (Faking It (TV 2014))
10. it feels better biting down by justimpolite (Faking It (TV 2014))
11. Happy Without Me by spasticandviolent (Faking It (TV 2014))
12. Lesbian One Shots by AWriterWhoJustExists (Marvel Cinematic Universe, iZombie (TV), more)
13. I and Love and You by tamaraface (Faking It (TV 2014))
14. All Things Taboo by Theladylazarus (Faking It (TV 2014))
15. Random Texts and Pizza Girls by forbiddenquill (Faking It (TV 2014))
16. Damn, Lauren. by forbiddenquill (Faking It (TV 2014))
17. Holding On To You by ridakulous (Faking It (TV 2014))
18. I Can't Let Him Win by spasticandviolent (Faking It (TV 2014))
19. Give Me Love by forbiddenquill (Faking It (TV 2014))
20. (you are) the girl that i've been dreaming of by dollsome (Faking It (TV 2014))