Fics like Unexpected Instincts
If Chris wanted to fill an Ashley-shaped void he'd be at a bar with a girl, not in the wilderness with a monster masquerading as his best friend. Ashley is pretty and timid, and she likes old romance movies and talking around her feelings instead of spilling them out all over the floor. Josh is the opposite of all those things. "You're pretty," Chris says out of nowhere, and Josh wonders how much of that he said out loud.
You may also like
- Let It Be Yesterday, Or Tomorrow by walkydeads (Until Dawn (Video Game))
- the balance book by coldmackerel (Until Dawn (Video Game))
- The Price of Virginity by TheLastBrosky (Until Dawn (Video Game))
- If Only For A Moment by orphan_account (Until Dawn (Video Game))
- Too Close For Comfort by aestheticAshes (Until Dawn (Video Game))
- “Just don’t let go of me, okay?” by The_Heart_of_Leo (Until Dawn (Video Game))
- I Trust You by slightlyrabid (Until Dawn (Video Game))
- ☆ Melle's Kinktober 2022: Supermassive Games Edition ☆ by RottenCaramel (The Dark Pictures: House of Ashes (Video Game), Until Dawn (Video Game), more)
- Save Your Tears by Dinodesu (Until Dawn (Video Game))
- I could be your perfect disaster, you could be my ever after by queenlara (Until Dawn (Video Game))
- Blood Sport by notyourbro (Until Dawn (Video Game))
- Rainy Nights and Ear Pains by PistachioGlow (Until Dawn (Video Game))
- Until Dawn: Heart of Ice by saintscorpio (Until Dawn (Video Game))
- ain't that somethin' by shatteredhourglass (Until Dawn (Video Game))
- Silly's Kinktober extravaganza 2026! by sillysowa (Marvel, Marvel Cinematic Universe, more)
- leave the horror here by provocation (Until Dawn (Video Game))
- is my name safe in your mouth? by roses_and_riots (Until Dawn (Video Game))
- Hold Me Down by Junesong (Until Dawn (Video Game))
- A Road Paved With Good Intentions by Emerald%20Embers (Until Dawn (Video Game))
- and I tried to hold these secrets inside me by queenlara (Until Dawn (Video Game))