Fics like show a little loving (shine a little light on me)

Out of everyone in her friend group, she developed a crush on the one person that was off limits, not only because he was her best friend’s brother but because it was the oldest cliché in the book. Or: In an effort to get over her unexpected feelings for Josh, Sam decides to avoid him. Things don’t go as planned.

You may also like

  1. is my name safe in your mouth? by roses_and_riots (Until Dawn (Video Game))
  2. Dislocated by StickyDog (Until Dawn (Video Game))
  3. and I tried to hold these secrets inside me by queenlara (Until Dawn (Video Game))
  4. ☆ Melle's Kinktober 2022: Supermassive Games Edition ☆ by RottenCaramel (The Dark Pictures: House of Ashes (Video Game), Until Dawn (Video Game), more)
  5. Let It Be Yesterday, Or Tomorrow by walkydeads (Until Dawn (Video Game))
  6. I always knew that I would find someone like you to make me right by LemonTwister (Until Dawn (Video Game))
  7. I'll Make It Right by memoriesofrain (Until Dawn (Video Game))
  8. the balance book by coldmackerel (Until Dawn (Video Game))
  9. Staring in the Devil’s Eyes by roses_and_riots (Until Dawn (Video Game))
  10. Prom Night by Hanndigo (Until Dawn (Video Game))
  11. Full of Surprises by notyourbro (Until Dawn (Video Game))
  12. one last time by bryndentully (Until Dawn (Video Game))
  13. Join by INMH (Until Dawn (Video Game))
  14. Gathering the Audience by UnderEarthFilms (RWBY, Re:ゼロから始める異世界生活 | Re:Zero Starting Life in Another World (Anime), more)
  15. The Cave by provocation (Until Dawn (Video Game))
  16. Switched by AmethystFaerieDragon (Until Dawn (Video Game))
  17. leave the horror here by provocation (Until Dawn (Video Game))
  18. Death Battle Ideas S9 Bonus by TheGametimer (Death Battle (Web Series), Multi-Fandom, more)
  19. Time and Mercy by The_Heart_of_Leo (Until Dawn (Video Game))
  20. I Trust You by slightlyrabid (Until Dawn (Video Game))