Fics like First One Loses

Everything was a game to Derek, and Casey knew it. Yet she indulged him, and she also knew it. But when Emily misinterprets her during a conversation and implies that Casey has feelings for her stepbrother, it's not a game anymore. Not when she can't trust her own heart. Not when it puts everyone's lives in jeopardy.

You may also like

1. To Get To Know Your Heart by Shommey99 (Life with Derek)
2. Love Given Unsought by ConcordiaChaos (Life with Derek)
3. even if it's a lie by anniebibananie (Life with Derek)
4. There! Right There! by Loverlylo (Life with Derek)
5. A Kind of Merry War by blithers (Life with Derek)
6. forget it by Thetwelfthletter (Life with Derek)
7. How To Play Charades by youcallitwinter (Life with Derek)
8. Serenity by Born2read (Life with Derek)
9. Stranger Than Fiction by NeoVenus22 (Life with Derek)
10. Changing on the Fly by cacophonous_noise (Life with Derek)
11. 'cause you’re the one that sparked this by irish_urn (Life with Derek)
12. This Is Life With Derek by justcallmedaisy (Life with Derek)
13. Different for Girls by unoriginal_liz (Life with Derek)
14. Stay by RollyPratt, UntoldGalaxies (Life with Derek)
15. ∞ by RollyPratt (Life with Derek)
16. For a Good Time, Call... by RollyPratt (Life with Derek)
17. A Tale of Two Cities by unoriginal_liz (Life with Derek, Press Gang)
18. Your Heart Says Otherwise by abitcfstardust (Life with Derek)
19. Sleepwalk To Me by emef (Life with Derek)
20. rules of engagement by copacet (Life with Derek)