Fics like Sutter Creek

The year is 1851 and Dean Winchester has finally found steady work after striking out during the gold rush and roaming aimlessly in the three years since his pa died. But when his brother Sam is threatened by the Marauders, a notorious band of outlaws, Dean must drop all and come to his rescue. As he and Sam try to evade the Marauders, they run into someone from Dean’s past and Dean realizes his life will truly never be the same again. Cas Novak has been plagued with nightmares and a desire for vengeance ever since a fateful day involving the Marauders. When he chances upon a familiar face—one he never expected to see again—he seizes the opportunity to finally get revenge on the outlaws. But with this unexpected encounter comes more than he ever bargained for.

You may also like

1. True as It Can Be by whelvenwings (Supernatural)
2. a turn of the earth by microcomets (Supernatural)
3. Vagabonds by chevrolangels (Supernatural)
4. The Last Moonlight Serenade by gankyourdarlings (Supernatural)
5. It's The End of the World (As We Know It) by tiamatv (Supernatural)
6. Passing Stranger by Astra_Wards (Supernatural)
7. the more you love a memory by deancaskiss (Supernatural)
8. The State of You by TrenchcoatBaby (Supernatural)
9. champagne problems by big_wet_cas_eyes (Supernatural)
10. Make a Wish (series) by Nachsie (Supernatural)
11. Breathing Into You by casblackfeathers (Supernatural)
12. tell me about the dream by playedwright (Supernatural)
13. Under The Midnight Sun by NorthernSparrow (Supernatural)
14. The Archer and The Squire by expectingtofly (Supernatural)
15. Don't Kill the Messenger by pingnova (Supernatural, Stigmata (1999))
16. The Exception to Every Rule by MittenWraith (Supernatural)
17. He's the Man by teller_of_tales_and_hero_of_songs (Supernatural)
18. The Shawnee Trail by emmbrancsxx0 (Supernatural)
19. Partnered by K_K_TiBal (Supernatural)
20. When the Magnolias bloom by Flurry_X (Supernatural)