Fics like heartbreaker

Evan was prepared to hate Casey's new girlfriend. The last thing he expected was to actually like her.

You may also like

1. hold me till I fall asleep by takemebacktothenightwemet (Atypical (TV 2017))
2. Then What Happened? by CaptainCountdown (Atypical (TV 2017))
3. watch you grow, watch you leap by phoenix_inthe_fire (Atypical (TV 2017))
4. You Are the Best Thing (That's Ever Been Mine) by sweeterthankarma (Atypical (TV 2017))
5. I love you for infinity (times infinity times infinity) by Kidfish (Atypical (TV 2017))
6. That’s my girl by Woody39 (Atypical (TV 2017))
7. get you the moon by voidpen (Legacies (TV 2018), The Vampire Diaries (TV), more)
8. maybe you're the (girl of my dreams) by Toucanna, corvidyke (Atypical (TV 2017))
9. Back To You by randomrayne2 (Atypical (TV 2017))
10. Izzie and the New Kid by ladstars (Atypical (TV 2017))
11. I Know You’re Feeling It Too by lesbiwlw (Atypical (TV 2017))
12. Arachnophobia by not_here_leave_a_message (Atypical (TV 2017))
13. god, it's brutal out here by neverbethesaame (Atypical (TV 2017))
14. you could be anything out there (butterflies flying in the air) by orphan_account (Atypical (TV 2017))
15. Runner Runner by Lysander12 (Atypical (TV 2017))
16. That Way by orphan_account (The Wilds (TV 2020), Atypical (TV 2017))
17. Between Us (One shot series) Casey and Izzie from Atypical x Deena + Sam from Fear Street by godblessyoubaby (Atypical (TV 2017), Fear Street Trilogy (TV))
18. I Don't Want To Lose by BigWordsAndSuch (Atypical (TV 2017))
19. you’re one of the few things that i’m sure of by orphan_account (Atypical (TV 2017))
20. the ice that slips down my spine (from having you on my mind) by Kidfish (Atypical (TV 2017))