Fics like New All Over Again

Dean and Cas as childhood sweethearts separated as teenagers who have been searching for each other for years without success. Against all odds, they reunite in the middle of Times Square at midnight on New Year’s Eve.

You may also like

1. romance painted on the screen, echoing you and me by deancaskiss (Supernatural)
2. I'll Go With You by jscribbles (Supernatural)
3. Domestic by tiamatv (Supernatural)
4. Alley Cat by Starmouse123 (Supernatural, His Dark Materials - Philip Pullman)
5. In All Senses of the Word by surlybobbies (Supernatural)
6. Note to Self: Cas Loves You by almaasi (Supernatural)
7. Revenge of the Text by MittenWraith (Supernatural)
8. The Way You Didn't Go by aeli_kindara (Supernatural)
9. Twenty ways to say I love you by dreamline (Supernatural)
10. to make a beginning by 1astofthereal1s (Supernatural)
11. The Little Things by followyourenergy (Supernatural)
12. I'm The Opposite of Amnesia by Why_do_you_want_to_know (Supernatural)
13. foundations by rhinestoneangels (Supernatural)
14. in my eyes (you're second to none) by enochianprayer (Supernatural)
15. I'm Dreamin' of a Grey Christmas by almaasi (Supernatural)
16. Actual Disney Princess by centreoftheselights (Supernatural, Disney Princesses, more)
17. Koinophilia by tiamatv (Supernatural)
18. Back in Time for Dinner by Lottiethroughthelookingglass (Supernatural)
19. The Parent Trap Only Works If You're Identical by FollowingButterflies (Supernatural)
20. the world matters nothing by Philyra912 (Supernatural)