Fics like Something That Never Was Mine

Nathan is finding it hard to fall in love with Lexie, and even harder to make her fall in love with him. Lexie is not interested in either of those things happening. Duke wants a chance with Audrey's new, wilder personality, even if it means he'll have to die for Haven. As if all that wasn't enough, they're still dealing with the troubles.

You may also like

1. By These Broken Wings, Shall We Be Carried by Jadzibelle (Haven (TV))
2. strays on a stale sea by gendernoncompliant (Haven (TV))
3. Powerful (with a Little Bit of Tender) by polytropic (Haven (TV))
4. Forever Together, Forever Alive by KaelsMiscellany (Haven (TV))
5. faults and cracks by slybrunette (Haven (TV))
6. Live and Let Live (But Don't Let Go) by Parker_Haven_Wuornos (Haven (TV))
7. the only right i have wronged by gendernoncompliant (Haven (TV))
8. i'm dying not to hurt you by tiltingheartand (Haven (TV))
9. What Makes A Home by GreyHaven, YumeArashi (Haven (TV))
10. Nothing Stops the Dreams... by KaelsMiscellany (Haven (TV))
11. Maybe all three of us...? by GreyHaven (Haven (TV))
12. Help me, I’m in Hell by PinkSparkleUnicorn (Haven (TV))
13. dance with a devil on your back by gendernoncompliant (Haven (TV))
14. Welcome To Cascade - Broken Snow by Paula%20Cas (NCIS, The Sentinel (TV), more)
15. Witchcraft and Curses by CookieDoughMe (Haven (TV), Witches of East End (TV))
16. Obsession by JCapasso (Haven (TV))
17. hologram of skin and bones by slybrunette (Haven (TV))
18. Dawn by JCapasso (Haven (TV))
19. as bad as it looks by gendernoncompliant (Haven (TV))
20. Let Us Love You by GreyHaven (Haven (TV))