Fics like Without Thinking

Dean sleeps with a guy at a party for the first time in his life. Castiel is beautiful and confident and very good in bed, and after that fateful night, Dean desperately wants to date him. Castiel just doesn't seem to get the hint.

You may also like

1. The Last I Love You by clown_ish (Supernatural)
2. Off my mind by ILoveFANFic (Supernatural)
3. O is for [Good] Omens by vipjuly (Supernatural)
4. Fragments by FieryAngel (Supernatural)
5. Party Favours. by psyleedee (Supernatural)
6. Till I Shatter by Rehtaeh_Elocin (Supernatural)
7. Insatiable by bestGuesses, leangreencastielmachine (Supernatural)
8. Collared by Nerdylittleangelenthusiast (Supernatural)
9. A Little Closer. by castiellovesrainbows (Supernatural)
10. Entrepreneurship in the Time of COVID by FieryAngel (Supernatural)
11. Dean's Bucket List of 'Naughty Things To Do with Castiel' - Part 5 by dearwanderingreader (Supernatural)
12. Profound Kisses by BENKA79 (Supernatural)
13. Feather Tickler by FieryAngel (Supernatural)
14. His Prayer by bestGuesses (Supernatural)
15. closer yet, deeper still by avyssoseleison (Supernatural)
16. Love in the Morning by Chiyume (Supernatural)
17. Eye of the Storm. by psyleedee (Supernatural)
18. I’ll have what he’s having by ILoveFANFic (Supernatural)
19. When It Comes to Being Loved by Sass_Master (Supernatural)
20. Dean, What's A Top? by orphan_account (Supernatural)