Fics like The Tale of the Terrible Weretortise

It's Halloween night, and everyone is as excited as ever! Just before everybody can get to their plans for this year, tragedy strikes! A beast has appeared in Free, Country USA and it is up to Homestar Runner and his friends to save the day! [The following text is written in SCRIPT formatting, as it is intended to be a fan episode] Costumes are as follows: Homestar- Uncle Jesse (Full House) Marzipan- She-ra (reboot) Strong Bad- Space Ghost Strong Mad- Kingpin (Into the Spiderverse) Strong Sad- Elton John The Cheat- Kid that gets killed first in (IT) Coach Z- Lil Nas X Bubs- Merchant (Resident Evil 4) Homsar- Sans Undertale King of Town- Tide Pod (yes really) The Poopsmith- Ash (Evil Dead) Pom Pom- UFO

You may also like

  1. Worst-Case Scenario by PancakeBatter (Homestar Runner)
  2. The Heist of a Lifetime! by college_knockout (Homestar Runner)
  3. Some Pun About Falling For You by razzafrazzle (Homestar Runner)
  4. Tales from the Inventory by CaptMickey (Poker Night at the Inventory (Video Game), The Venture Bros, more)
  5. Everything sticks until it goes away (it goes home) by homegrownRagamuffin, nugatoryExtravagance (Homestar Runner)
  6. Five-Week-Aversary (Homestar Runner)
  7. It's a Matter of Time! by tdougland (Homestar Runner)
  8. Hi-larious Homoerotic Cartoon Hijinks (Homestar Runner)
  9. My Words Which I Speak by orphan_account (Homestar Runner)
  10. Valid-Times Day by orphan_account (Homestar Runner)
  11. A Whole New Perspective by kitsuneroach (Homestar Runner)
  12. WPaRG Intermission: Coming Out by MultiFanGirlWickedPony, chelonianmobile (Disney - All Media Types, Wallace & Gromit, more)
  13. Fake ID by dangeresque%20too (Homestar Runner)
  14. Homestar Runner assists Strong Bad with his T shot, and then they watch Robocop by sharkfan75 (Homestar Runner)
  15. Whoops. by orphan_account (Homestar Runner)
  16. Sleepstar Walker by tdougland (Homestar Runner)
  17. Everybody loves The Homestar Runner by Grossion5z (Homestar Runner)
  18. Two Weirdos from an Another Universe play Matchmaker with Strong Bad & Homestar Runner by KingFranPetty (Homestar Runner)
  19. Couch'd by chunkybingo, jovishark (Homestar Runner)
  20. Twice Times by tdougland (Homestar Runner)