Fics like Monsters in Your Closet

When Castiel goes on a hunt alone and is caught by a particular FBI team, the brothers do something they never thought they’d have to. They kidnap SSA Spencer Reid to make an exchange. But being kidnapped by delusional serial killers is nothing like Spencer thought it would be.

You may also like

1. Little Miracles by KatinaMoon (Criminal Minds (US TV))
2. a turn of the earth by microcomets (Supernatural)
3. Morning Star by LittleMissXanda (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, Supernatural)
4. psalm 40:2 by unicornpoe (Supernatural)
5. Not your typical damsel in distress by PepperonyOwl (Criminal Minds (US TV), Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling)
6. Like Glass by entanglednow (Supernatural)
7. Long Forgotten Enemies by littlebear62007 (Percy Jackson and the Olympians - Rick Riordan, Percy Jackson and the Olympians & Related Fandoms - All Media Types, more)
8. Peanut Butter-Pumpkin Wedding Cake by Sparseparsley (Supernatural)
9. He Was Left on the Steps of the FBI in a Basket by schrijverr (Criminal Minds (US TV))
10. The BAU is No Place for a Bat by Rosie_the_Fanfic_Reader (Batman - All Media Types, Criminal Minds (US TV))
11. Single Malt, Double Life by mind_of_emmette (NCIS (TV 2003), Criminal Minds (US TV))
12. What Comes After by AlbusCorvus (Criminal Minds (US TV), Supernatural)
13. Strandlines by aeli_kindara (Supernatural)
14. Twist and Shout by gabriel, standbyme (Supernatural)
15. things happen (they do, they do, and they do) by sobsicles (Supernatural)
16. Why it is a bad idea to capture Bats by CyborgV2 (Batman - All Media Types, Justice League - All Media Types, more)
17. Fanning the Flames by mandraco (Supernatural, Criminal Minds)
18. Love: A Retrospective by xylodemon (Supernatural)
19. Temporarily Misappropriating the BAU by L3T5_G3T_KR4K3N (Teen Wolf (TV), Criminal Minds (US TV))
20. There's Only One Sure Thing That I Know by blinkiesays (Supernatural)