Fics like What Greater Gift

Story idea: The most wanted woman in town has announced that she’ll only marry the one who can open her front door with the key around her cat’s neck. Many men try to hunt the cat down, chase and trap it, but to no avail, the cat is simply too quick, smart and clever, and always finds a way to evade and avoid them. You are the first one to figure out the obvious: Do not chase the cat. The cat is befriendable. Get the cat to trust you, to genuinely enjoy your company, and you can hang out with the cat. You may eventually be allowed to touch the cat. The cat will freely let you take the key. From a prompt found on Tumblr. Saw this and I couldn't resist a Destiel AU, and I've been wanting to write Witch!Cas for ages. Link to tumblr prompt will be in the end notes—be forewarned, contains spoilers!

You may also like

1. Strangers on a Bus by Terene (Supernatural)
2. The Five People You Meet in Heaven by chevrolangels (Supernatural)
3. Syncopation by K_K_TiBal (Supernatural)
4. Avoiding the Road by thepinupchemist (Supernatural)
5. Rest in Pieces by xylodemon (Supernatural)
6. The Truth by whelvenwings (Supernatural)
7. Let It Be Me by queenannabethwinchester (Supernatural)
8. After All These Years by peanutbutterjelly-pie (Supernatural)
9. It's a Small World (aka the Worst Ride at Disneyland) by ireadhpinenochian (Supernatural)
10. Run Boy Run by DarcyDelaney (Supernatural)
11. Outrun My Gun by thraced (Supernatural)
12. Here, bullet, here by a_good_soldier (Supernatural)
13. Adagio by noangelsinthegarrison (Supernatural)
14. Collapsed Rainbows by suckerfordeansfreckles (Supernatural)
15. Home is Where by ChasingRabbits (Supernatural)
16. Dean Winchester, Straight Shooter by triedunture (Supernatural)
17. Have Books, Will Travel by palominopup (Supernatural)
18. Critical Mass by ireallyhatecornnuts (Supernatural)
19. Smoke In the Mirror by letters_of_stars (Supernatural)
20. Without Further Ado by almaasi (Supernatural)