Fics like A Thrill I've Never Known

Reader has been a lone wolf for a long time, and intends for it to stay that way. However, she soon realises that having a little company and help from others isn’t so bad. Super slow burn fic, loosely following the events of the game (so full of spoilers), it may not necessarily be in perfect chronological order/follow canon completely. I'll be changing certain things up whenever I see fit, and while some characters may die, Arthur will not. It's going to have smut in it later down the line! Finally, this is unlikely to be completely historically accurate since I'm not a historian, but I will try and be as accurate as possible :)

You may also like

  1. May The Sunrise Bring Hope Where It Once Was Forgotten by deathmallow (Red Dead Redemption, Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  2. Let Me Love You Anyway by Elmhawthorne (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  3. Blind Fortunes by Gingersnap741 (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  4. Real Life Love Is Under the Mirror of the Surface by Nigaki (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  5. Rearrange the Stars by whyyouacknsocraycray (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  6. Kinktober 2025 (video game men x reader) ୨ৎ by sinonimgirl (Biohazard | Resident Evil (Gameverse), The Last of Us (Video Games), more)
  7. Enter, Pursued By Defeat by PurpleArrowzandLeather (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  8. old friend (we nearly drowned for such a silly thing) by trains_arent_real (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  9. Valuables by surveycorpsjean (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  10. Looking Down The Sights by SoggyCrossis (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  11. the old therebefore (when nothing is left anymore) by wisteriawoven (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  12. Prodigy by MXBVSL (Parahumans Series - Wildbow, Multi-Fandom, more)
  13. One Last Time by whyyouacknsocraycray (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  14. What Matters by PurpleArrowzandLeather (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  15. Learning to Steal by Kiwicane (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  16. Sunrise by pipdepop (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  17. Ebb and Flow by nemvous (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  18. Redbird by Doc_Friday (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  19. You Are My Sunshine by BetweenTownleys (Red Dead Redemption, Red Dead Redemption (Video Games), more)
  20. And In The Morning I Loved You Too by pipdepop (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))