Fics like A New Toy

Marco orders a rather... peculiar item online. When Star manages to get her hands on it before he does, she decides to confront him about it. Needless to say, things take a turn for the weird and wild when Star decides to "break in" her bestie's new toy.

You may also like

  1. Practice Makes Perfect by WriteAnon (Star vs. the Forces of Evil)
  2. Bloody Premonitions by Ltl_maker (Star vs. the Forces of Evil)
  3. Marco vs. the Forces of Lust by Writer_of_the_Future (Star vs. the Forces of Evil)
  4. A Lesson in Demon Biology by SpyroForLife (Star vs. the Forces of Evil)
  5. Buenos Diaz by OwTheEdge (Star vs. the Forces of Evil)
  6. Cross Country Cutie Collection: Gravity Falls by OwTheEdge (Gravity Falls, Star vs. the Forces of Evil)
  7. Under the dim red light (Star vs. the Forces of Evil)
  8. Marshmallow the Matchmaker by cami611 (Star vs. the Forces of Evil)
  9. Losing isn't so bad by Mae25 (Star vs. the Forces of Evil)
  10. You Have (many) New Messages by Thornrose270 (Amphibia (Cartoon), Gravity Falls, more)
  11. Tell the Truth by Oliver_966 (Star vs. the Forces of Evil)
  12. Piles of Lemons: Long Live King Marco by Geo_Soul (Star vs. the Forces of Evil)
  13. You Mean a Latte to Me by delsol (Star vs. the Forces of Evil)
  14. Compilation:College Dayz:The Lust Madness Fiasco (A Kinky Experience spin-off) & Stories from the DQU fic-verse by Sketchfan (Helluva Boss (Web Series), Hazbin Hotel (Cartoon), more)
  15. MWILF X STUD by FanficThinker (American Dad!, Family Guy (Cartoon), more)
  16. A Habit Hard to Break by Akeara4, Grade_A_Sexual (Star vs. the Forces of Evil)
  17. Endeavors of Diplomacy by Azzandra (Star vs. the Forces of Evil)
  18. Blood Moon Mania by Gemsom (Star vs. the Forces of Evil)
  19. Chestnut stud and more across the multiverse by Sketchfan (Dragon Ball, Steven Universe (Cartoon), more)
  20. Venti Plus's Collection of Shorts by Ventiplus (小林さんちのメイドラゴン | Kobayashi-san Chi no Maid Dragon | Miss Kobayashi's Dragon Maid, RWBY, more)