Fics like Belief Extraordinary

Try as she might, Sarah Everett never could be normal. One night, her deepest wishes come true when she's swept away to Neverland, the island of eternal youth and misfit boys. But Neverland is neither all she imagined, nor all it appears. Between the island's dark jungles and devilish(ly attractive) inhabitants, Sarah will need every ounce of her wits to survive. But the boy king of Neverland is in for a surprise. Unbeknownst to anyone, herself most of all, the most dangerous thing on the island? May very well be Sarah.

You may also like

1. You Gotta Play Dirty by amycarey (Once Upon a Time (TV))
2. Striking Down Roots by lostlilsnail (Once Upon a Time (TV))
3. The Fear that Haunts Me by HoneybeeRae (Peter Pan (2003), Peter Pan - J. M. Barrie, more)
4. The Not-so-Evil Princess by Rhino (Once Upon a Time (TV), Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. (TV))
5. Again, For the First Time by iam_new_here (Once Upon a Time (TV))
6. Thread Softly by Whistle_Silver (Once Upon a Time (TV))
7. This Graceful Path by unfolded73 (Once Upon a Time (TV))
8. Second Star to the Right by aquariusgirl98 (Once Upon a Time (TV), Peter Pan - J. M. Barrie, more)
9. For Better or Worse by theharpergrey (Once Upon a Time (TV))
10. Never Land by the_monster_girl (Peter Pan - J. M. Barrie, Peter Pan (2003), more)
11. Whatever This Is by afictionado (Once Upon a Time (TV))
12. Powerless by isthatmyjacket_wandanat (Once Upon a Time (TV))
13. Strangeness & Charm by heroesfading (Once Upon a Time (TV))
14. Down East Decisions by FlyYouFools (Once Upon a Time (TV))
15. North Star by Daryah (Once Upon a Time (TV))
16. A different approach by TheTrueFro (Once Upon a Time (TV))
17. In the Velvet Darkness by devje (Once Upon a Time (TV))
18. The Ripple Effect - A Captain Swan Tale by TheDarkDragonfly (Once Upon a Time (TV))
19. The Pirate's Treasure by MorsXmordrE (Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs (1937), Peter Pan & Related Fandoms, more)
20. Over The Town Line by SpookshowBabyx (Once Upon a Time (TV))