Fics like Mr. Lodge We Can't

Being attracted to your best friend’s dad can be hard, especially with him tempting you while your friends are in the next room

You may also like

1. The Mixing of Sides by CrashHale (Riverdale (TV 2017))
2. Careful Who You Put On A Show For by omgspnfanfiction (Riverdale (TV 2017), The Avengers (Marvel Movies), more)
3. If You're Under Him, You Ain't Gettin' Over Him by omgspnfanfiction (Riverdale (TV 2017), Supernatural (TV 2005))
4. Nurture My Sins by kagszzy (Riverdale (TV 2017))
5. Southside High by noorakardemmomesaetre (Riverdale (TV 2017))
6. Straight Girls Get Married on Facebook All the Time by Alsike (Riverdale (TV 2017))
7. wild tonic in the rain by punk_rock_yuppie (Riverdale (TV 2017))
8. We are all Embers (From the Same Fire) by DarveysBughead (Riverdale (TV 2017))
9. Some Doors Are Best Left Unopen by omgspnfanfiction (Supernatural, Riverdale (TV 2017))
10. The Boy on the Bike by SereneCalamity (Riverdale (TV 2017), Archie Comics, more)
11. The blonde in the window by quinnstar16 (Riverdale (TV 2017))
12. Dandelion Clocks by IndianSummer13 (Riverdale (TV 2017))
13. Boyfriends Cum and Go, But Daddies Are Forever by omgspnfanfiction (Riverdale (TV 2017), Supernatural (TV 2005))
14. Movie Night by Pigzxo (Riverdale (TV 2017))
15. what's brooklyn between strangers by gabrieeella (Riverdale (TV 2017))
16. Pay the Piper by lilylemoncakes (Riverdale (TV 2017))
17. what's a sleepover without a little smut? by cherryliqueur (Riverdale (TV 2017))
18. Snakes and Crowns by PopsAfterDark (Riverdale (TV 2017))
19. An Unexpected Christmas Encounter by omgspnfanfiction (Riverdale (TV 2017))
20. The Truth Will Always be the Truth by punk_rock_yuppie (Riverdale (TV 2017))