Fics like First and Only

Single bachelor Dean bets he can have sex more times within a calendar year than his happily-married brother. But when Castiel – Dean’s roommate, best friend, and total virgin – asks Dean to be his First, Dean’s plan to bed numerous strangers goes up in smoke. Over the weeks, then the months, Cas becomes his go-to guy. His “fuck buddy”, if you will. But that doesn’t sound right. It doesn’t feel right. Dean was Cas’ First, but now he wants to be Cas’ Only. Now he’s gotta figure out how the heck to court a guy he’s successfully wooed a hundred times already.

You may also like

1. Protect and Serve by jupiter_james (Supernatural)
2. Operation Jealousy by Annie%20D (Supernatural)
3. Inevitable Homoeroticism in Spanish Romantic Heroes by prosopopeya (Supernatural)
4. This Means War by thepinupchemist (Supernatural)
5. Our Bodies, Possessed By Light by obstinatrix (Supernatural)
6. I Like You (Like Me) by Carmexgirl (Supernatural)
7. Special by rosethomass (Supernatural)
8. Return to Sender by aileenrose (Supernatural)
9. Tempest of Oblivion by thepinupchemist (Supernatural)
10. Syncopation by K_K_TiBal (Supernatural)
11. Monsters by Miss_Lv (Supernatural)
12. Of Flowers and Flours by lemonsorbae (Supernatural)
13. Do You Want to Play With Magic? by fairychangeling (Supernatural)
14. Outrun My Gun by thraced (Supernatural)
15. Neglect by vanishingact (Supernatural)
16. On the House by relucant (Supernatural)
17. One Species Too Many by wallmakerrelict (Supernatural)
18. Noveltea & Coffee by rustling_pages (Supernatural)
19. Carve Your Name Into My Arm by thraced (Supernatural)
20. Any Little Heartbreak by followthattardis (Supernatural)