Fics like Never Have I Ever (or, The Hands of Caleb Widogast)

“Never have I ever had sex,” says Jester, an easy opener, a low blow – and Caleb, along with the rest of them bar Caduceus, drinks. (The Mighty Nein decide to play a drinking game, and Caleb recalls some of Bren's experiences with sex.)

You may also like

  1. babe, there's something magic about you by hoper_dreamer (Critical Role (Web Series))
  2. sleeping in the shadow of an other self by nonwal (Critical Role (Web Series))
  3. a certain future by wristpockets (Critical Role (Web Series))
  4. Professor Widogast as Observed By His Third Year Transmutation Class by GoringWriting (Critical Role (Web Series))
  5. Tactile Stimulation by SnubbingApollo (Critical Role (Web Series))
  6. Careful Steps by chaya (Critical Role (Web Series))
  7. We Take Care Of Our Own by PrincessAmericaChavez (Critical Role (Web Series))
  8. 5 times Molly flirted with Caleb (in infernal) by Fuckdarcy (Critical Role (Web Series))
  9. Weirdos Stick Together by RhoscPixie (Critical Role (Web Series), Critical Role (Wildemount Campaign))
  10. grasping dark, reaching gold by lakrisrot (Critical Role (Web Series))
  11. Professor Widogast is Fucking Weird by GoringWriting (Critical Role (Web Series))
  12. Eight of Swords by SwissArmyKnife (Critical Role (Web Series))
  13. the weakness to fall by howlingheartdemigod (Critical Role (Web Series))
  14. A Mote of Possibility by SwissArmyKnife (Critical Role (Web Series))
  15. back against the wall by wastrelwoods (Critical Role (Web Series))
  16. Fresh Starts by TherapyBard (Critical Role (Web Series))
  17. Labor of Love by OMGitsgreen (Critical Role (Web Series))
  18. Where Hope Blooms and Love Grows by EmiAliceinWonderland (Critical Role (Web Series))
  19. A Fur Lined Cloak by chaya (Critical Role (Web Series))
  20. Echoes and Memories by bfketh (Critical Role (Web Series))