Fics like If It's a Make-Believe (I Say It Ain't)

Season 12. It's Sam's fault, really. Dean testing out all his ridiculous pick-up lines on him was torturous enough. Knowing they were going to be used on other people stung a bit more. But even despite all of that...he still should've kept his damn mouth shut.

You may also like

1. Man in the Mirror by Colette_Capricious (Supernatural)
2. Double Jeopardy by alwaysthrowsscissors (Supernatural)
3. Kiss the Cook by alwaysthrowsscissors (Supernatural)
4. Chemical High by themegalosaurus (Supernatural)
5. A-Z: NSFW Edition by faequeentitania (Supernatural)
6. the archivist by deadlybride (Supernatural)
7. All I Want Is to Have My Peace of Mind by orphan_account (Supernatural)
8. A Sword and Shield Victorious by dreamlittleyo (Supernatural)
9. If You Like to Gamble, I Tell You I'm Your Man by orphan_account (Supernatural)
10. Betelgeuse by hellhoundsprey (Supernatural)
11. A Key to Every Door by dreamlittleyo, rivers_bend (Supernatural)
12. Love That's Gonna Break Me In Two by britomart_is (Supernatural)
13. I Could Tell You Why by Nutkin (Supernatural)
14. Trust Me to Take Care of You by butterflybeautyrush (Supernatural (TV 2005), Supernatural)
15. Sam Winchester and the Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Day by leonidaslion (Supernatural)
16. Claiming his Brother by FairyNiamh (Supernatural)
17. It's All In The Presentation by Jld71, Yonkyu (Supernatural)
18. You Took My Body and Played to Win by orphan_account (Supernatural)
19. I'm Still an Animal by thatsakitkat (Supernatural)
20. Burning Love Comes Once (In a Lifetime) by orphan_account (Supernatural)