Fics like Third Time's the Charm

"So you are virgins. Again."

You may also like

1. I Was Afraid When I Met You by GhostGarrison (Supernatural)
2. Between the Shadow and the Soul by Vee (Supernatural)
3. (A Blessing or) A Curse by lovegonestale (Supernatural)
4. Stay in Touch by Cuda (Supernatural)
5. I Know It When I See It by Balder12 (Supernatural)
6. Hold Me by Fallynleaf (Supernatural)
7. small shifts by deancascore (Supernatural)
8. Plant Pathologists vs. Zombie Lawyers by Annie%20D (Supernatural)
9. The People Our Parents Created by ArchOfImagine (Supernatural)
10. A List of Things by subchesters (Supernatural)
11. Closer to Heaven and Closer to You by Epiphanyx7 (Supernatural)
12. Brothers from Hell by Zetal (Supernatural)
13. Run your fingers through my soul by queerly_it_is (Supernatural)
14. Run Right; or Lie by orphan_account (Supernatural)
15. Little Spark by cellard00rs (Supernatural)
16. In the Absence of a Breeze by rosethomass (Supernatural)
17. This Grace of Love is Mine Eye by orphan_account (Supernatural)
18. Lines by posingasme (Supernatural)
19. Be My Baby by Dawne_Diely (Supernatural)
20. Pictsie Dust by kototyph (Supernatural)