Fics like Picking Up the Pieces

John wasn't there when Mary Linton shattered Arthur's heart the first time, but he'd make damn sure he was there this time.

You may also like

  1. The Woman with the Red Lipstick by FeralCreature (Red Dead Redemption)
  2. high noon by captainamericagf (Red Dead Redemption)
  3. Sanders by dilangley (Red Dead Redemption)
  4. eye of the beholder by Yuu_chi (Red Dead Redemption)
  5. I Hold You by Some_Cowboah (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games), Red Dead Redemption)
  6. A New Start by girlwithapen109 (Red Dead Redemption, rdr2 - Fandom, more)
  7. Fata Morgana by BetweenTownleys (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games), Red Dead Redemption, more)
  8. nsfw alphabet. (arthur morgan edition) by orphan_account (Red Dead Redemption)
  9. Nobody Asked by The_Mad_Hatter (Red Dead Redemption)
  10. Call to Motion by mangochi (Red Dead Redemption, Red Dead Redemption 2)
  11. Quiet For So Long by KBstories (Red Dead Redemption)
  12. Taut by sciencefictioness (Red Dead Redemption)
  13. lay bare before me by what_on_io (Red Dead Redemption)
  14. May The Sunrise Bring Hope Where It Once Was Forgotten by deathmallow (Red Dead Redemption, Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  15. Hard times come again no more by dilangley (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games), Red Dead Redemption)
  16. A Matter Most Delicate by glyphsbowtie (Red Dead Redemption)
  17. The Gift of Giving by fleet_of_red (Red Dead Redemption, Red Dead Redemption 2)
  18. Wise Men Say (Only fools rush in) by AnUnreliableWriter (Red Dead Redemption)
  19. Wish Upon by Oscurita (Red Dead Redemption, Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  20. roads left in both of our shoes by imperfectkreis (Red Dead Redemption)