Fics like Best Birthday Ever

The boys decide to give Caleb an unconventional birthday gift

You may also like

1. In Another Life by Antarctica_or_bust (The Covenant (2006))
2. The Great Design Unfinished by QueenVee1, octobergryphon (Captain America (Movies), MCU, more)
3. Perchance to Dream by sparrowshellcat (The Covenant (2006))
4. Blue Eyes by BiteMyTongue_Ade (Twilight Series - All Media Types, The Covenant (2006))
5. Kiss and Control by deadlolidollie (The Covenant (2006))
6. The Slightest Touch (Is Heavy On Me) by mickeysixx (The Covenant (2006))
7. Birthday Feast by Mystik (The Covenant (2006))
8. All I Need Is You by BiteMyTongue_Ade (Twilight Series - All Media Types, The Covenant (2006))
9. All of You by bulma90_13 (Marvel Cinematic Universe, Captain America (Movies), more)
10. Rebellion by Xyl_3 (The Covenant (2006), Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling)
11. Talk Dirty To Me by mickeysixx (The Covenant (2006))
12. Truth and Lies by Eye_Greater_Than_Three (The Covenant (2006), Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling)
13. Private Party For Three by mickeysixx (The Covenant (2006))
14. to put away childish things by mickeysixx (The Covenant (2006))
15. Finding Myself With You by BiteMyTongue_Ade (Twilight Series - All Media Types, The Covenant (2006))
16. Eclipsed by sparrowshellcat (Pitch Black (2000), Buffy the Vampire Slayer, more)
17. The Only Thing That's Real by Antarctica_or_bust (The Covenant (2006))
18. Trust None of What You See (And Less of What You Hear) by sparrowshellcat (Buffy the Vampire Slayer, The Covenant (2006), more)
19. Burning Houses by domini_moonbeam (The Covenant (2006))
20. Endless Wonders by Eye_Greater_Than_Three (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, The Covenant (2006), more)