Fics like Moonshadow

A beautiful man walks out of the ocean and into Carlton’s town, wearing stolen clothes and a seal’s pelt. It’s a full moon. It’s 1590.

You may also like

1. The Road to Tikihama by unadrift (Psych)
2. Losing My Mind by janewestin (Psych)
3. And They Say Romance is Dead by pointyshades (Psych)
4. Murder by Something Something by trixietru (Psych)
5. The Hours That Are Passed by elles_letters (Psych)
6. 2 + 2 = More by copyallcatsandacrobats (Psych)
7. Confidentiality by sebviathan (Psych)
8. Safe by Zaxal (Psych)
9. Shawn and Lassie Do a Good, Good Thing by xDinahQueenx (Psych)
10. Prompts and Tiniest Things by aHostileRainbow (The Hobbit - All Media Types, Pocahontas (1995), more)
11. What's Gus Got To Do With It? by purewanderlust (Psych)
12. Six Degrees of Speculation by sebviathan (Psych)
13. Dirty Little Secret by Zaxal (Psych)
14. Dyslexic Heart by trixietru (Psych)
15. Hotel in California by moondragon23 (Psych)
16. Fics written for Queer Fest in '14 by Missy (Psych, The Simpsons, more)
17. A Tale as Old as Vegas, Baby by burglebezzlement (Psych)
18. It Sounds Uncommon Nonsense by sumokoala, travelinthedark (Criminal Minds, Psych)
19. Eidetic by MaelynnMeep (Psych)
20. The Walrus and the Guy Who Carpents by plainapple (Psych)