Fics like All According to Plan

For years Vicky has been trying, and failing, to win over Polly’s heart. Liam seems to have a similar problem with a certain demon. With prom right around the corner Vicky grows desperate. She strikes a deal with the vampire, and the two help each out serving as wingmen. Seems simple enough. That is until Vicky develops feelings for her partner.

You may also like

1. Is... he crying..? Whoops by Flippynote (Monster Prom (Visual Novel))
2. A deal with the Demon Prince by B0nico0 (Monster Prom (Visual Novel))
3. "I just wanted to buy my friend's groceries." by Chrisilium (Monster Prom (Visual Novel))
4. Yet Another Epic Character Elimination Reboot by Epichaxboi (Hades (Video Game 2018), DCU (Comics), more)
5. a simple dare, really by ceruleanskies (Monster Prom (Visual Novel))
6. Monster Prom: Senior Year by tenkay10 (Monster Prom (Visual Novel))
7. Thoughtless Rejection by Brruubba (Monster Prom (Visual Novel))
8. Successful Failure of a Plan by OwlWanderer (Monster Prom (Visual Novel))
9. How to Kiss a Demon Prince/How To Date an Eldritch Horror (Discontinued) by AllumAllium (Monster Prom (Visual Novel))
10. Be Less Chill (Monster Prom (Visual Novel))
11. Temptor by ELPhobia (Monster Prom (Visual Novel))
12. Three Weeks is a Lifetime by PhantomDreamshade (Monster Prom (Visual Novel))
13. drown the bed in kerosene and let your matches fall by dytabytes (Monster Prom (Visual Novel))
14. My First Kiss Went a Little Like...Hellfire and Brimstone by not_quite_a_human (Monster Prom (Visual Novel))
15. Demon Is Wooing Who? by bunnyscribe (Monster Prom (Visual Novel))
16. game night by pathtothetreeoflife (Monster Prom (Visual Novel))
17. Monster Prom: The Aftermath by an_undead_gamer_45 (Monster Prom (Visual Novel))
18. Milo and the extreme attachment to their mobile device by orphan_account (Monster Prom (Visual Novel))
19. i do adore by maplechaitea (Monster Prom (Visual Novel))
20. eldritch secrets by putyournamehere (Monster Prom (Visual Novel))