Fics like The Shape of Regret

Two years ago, Dean walked away from Castiel after discovering his biggest secret—that he’s a witch. Since then, Dean’s spent his days hunting alone, filling the emptiness inside with sex, booze, and the next case. When he gets a desperate call for help from Castiel, Dean doesn’t hesitate to go. But things in the small Maine town aren’t what they seem, especially when he comes face to face with Castiel, who insists he wasn’t the one to place the call. Dean’s been given an opportunity to fix his past mistakes, but it means working alongside a very bitter Castiel, and Benny, a local deputy with knowledge of the supernatural, to figure out what’s plaguing Newport and why it all seems fixated around Castiel.

You may also like

1. Tempest of Oblivion by thepinupchemist (Supernatural)
2. Return to Sender by aileenrose (Supernatural)
3. Imperfect Proposals by Fallen_Angel_Meg (Supernatural)
4. Along My Restless Palms by Sass_Master (Supernatural)
5. I'll Be Good by LittleAngelCassie (Supernatural)
6. Captured by RedheadedSuperhero (Supernatural)
7. Caged Flowers by Winglesss (Supernatural)
8. Neglect by vanishingact (Supernatural)
9. What Are The Odds? by Redamber79 (Supernatural)
10. What's up Doc by CBFirestarter (Supernatural)
11. Living Broken Adjacent by LittleAngelCassie (Supernatural)
12. Bender by vipjuly (Supernatural)
13. The Prodigal Bond by vipjuly (Supernatural)
14. The Meaning On My Skin by saltnhalo (Supernatural)
15. Bless the Broken Road by angelswatchingover (Supernatural)
16. From Grace and Uniform by ThursdaysWaywardWriter, saltnhalo (Supernatural)
17. A Reasonable Amount of Trouble by xylodemon (Supernatural)
18. Duck Duck Boots by almaasi (Supernatural)
19. Uninvited But Deeply Craved by SillyBlue (Supernatural)
20. The Adventures of Real Anal Sex (Starring Dean and Castiel) by tiptoe39 (Supernatural)