Fics like Bullet with Butterfly Wings

Anita encounters one of the Jets again many years later.

You may also like

1. If you were the winter, I know I'd be the snow by thembonesthembones (West Side Story (1961), West Side Story (2021))
2. People Trying by CheerioKinnie (West Side Story (1961), West Side Story (2021))
3. Give My Regards to Broadway by volunteerfd (Good Omens - Neil Gaiman & Terry Pratchett, Good Omens (TV), more)
4. Storms and Smokes by SixofCrowsBabies (West Side Story (1961))
5. One Last Dance at the Gym by birdinblue (West Side Story - Bernstein/Sondheim/Laurents, West Side Story (2021), more)
6. Womb to tomb was never a joke for them by thewoildisyeroister (West Side Story (2021), West Side Story (1961))
7. West Side Other Story by melanie1982 (West Side Story (1961))
8. A Place For Us by CitizenofUtopia (West Side Story (1961))
9. Start Over, Oh Darling by This_world_of_beautiful_monsters (West Side Story - Bernstein/Sondheim/Laurents, West Side Story (1961), more)
10. Falling Slowly by theflyingdalek (West Side Story (2021), West Side Story (1961), more)
11. interlude by annabeeus (West Side Story (2021), West Side Story (1961), more)
12. to be alone with you by junkyard_parade (West Side Story (1961), West Side Story (2020))
13. late night soda run by Alessgrosskid (West Side Story (1961))
14. Amor de Hermanos by dulce_chisme (West Side Story (1961), West Side Story (2021), more)
15. West Side Story but Riff and Bernardo are in Love by orphan_account (West Side Story (1961))
16. Through My Eyes by thevibrantruby (West Side Story (1961), West Side Story - Bernstein/Sondheim/Laurents, more)
17. Something by Meltha (West Side Story (1961))
18. Baby John Sickfic by dontshootforthestarsshoothigher (West Side Story (1961), West Side Story (2021))
19. Independence Wars by redletters (West Side Story (1961))
20. by the way, there's no escape (a Hungarian musical theatre ficlet collection) by Carmarthen (Ördögölő Józsiás - Tolcsvay/Tamási/Bori, Párizsi élet (Színház), more)