Fics like you, me, her, we

Then Maka said, "Papa, are you okay?" Before he could respond, Black Star exclaimed, shouting as he usually did, "Papa? What?" "Um....I thought Maka's father was....the current death scythe..." "He is," Soul informed. "This is her other dad."

You may also like

1. Bet on Me by espioc (Soul Eater)
2. Saving Grace by sojustifiable (Soul Eater)
3. Makes You Happy (to give it up gladly) by takesguts (Soul Eater)
4. Panties? What Panties? by fabulousanima (Soul Eater)
5. 「Various Anime Boys Seven Minutes in Heaven」 by WordsOfFate (Fullmetal Alchemist - All Media Types, Ao no Exorcist | Blue Exorcist, more)
6. Various X Reader [Multi-Fandom Book] by Bonkers4hatter (Hetalia: Axis Powers, Marvel Cinematic Universe, more)
7. The Reaping by ASongofSixpence (Soul Eater)
8. NOT LOVERS by makapedia (Soul Eater)
9. reunion by quillifer (Soul Eater)
10. Scars by iasant (Soul Eater)
11. Unrequited by infantblue, kallieflower (Soul Eater)
12. Crescendo by dirkygoodness (Soul Eater)
13. Dirty Blonde by MicrosuedeMouse (Soul Eater)
14. Cemetery Boy by Cocalolhh (Soul Eater (Anime & Manga), Soul Eater)
15. Saying No by chichirichick (Soul Eater)
16. Emina Games by Riapsed (Tokyo Ghoul, Kagerou Project, more)
17. Oneshots of the Many Fandoms by orphan_account (Kuroshitsuji | Black Butler, Ao no Exorcist | Blue Exorcist, more)
18. bite down hard, bite down by makapedia (Soul Eater)
19. If You Love Me Let Me Know by redphlox (Soul Eater)
20. Angel with a Shotgun by sillu (Soul Eater)