Fics like When the Coffee Mug Breaks

Carlton has never been happier. He's got a new home, a hot husband, and his arrest record has never been more impressive. Now he's just waiting for the other shoe to drop. When a serial killer with a fascination in Shawn surfaces in Santa Barbara, Carlton can't shake the feeling that his happiness is going to come to an abrupt end. [ Part 3 of Coffee Shop Saga ]

You may also like

1. By Whatever Beans Necessary by hawkeyedkoi (Psych (TV 2006))
2. Santa Barbara Sleuthing by thedoeeyedgirl (Criminal Minds (US TV), Psych (TV 2006))
3. The Smartest Dumb Person She's Ever Met by ObsidianCreates (Psych (TV 2006))
4. Seconds Before the Crash by hawkeyedkoi (Psych (TV 2006))
5. Hail Mary, Full of... Wait for iiiit… by left_four_right, tanzytechgem (Psych (TV 2006), Project Hail Mary (2026), more)
6. east with them and west within by ace8013, flashsideways (Psych (TV 2006))
7. Unforeseen Circumstances by GhostArtist (Psych (TV 2006))
8. Some Things are Better Off Forgotten by pasta_stuffed_possums (Psych (TV 2006))
9. Puppy Love by ParakeetProsciutto (Psych (TV 2006))
10. Don’t Stop Believing (In Me) by Azhreah (Psych (TV 2006))
11. Seriously, why? by KittyHowell (Psych (TV 2006))
12. Fear of Forests by pasta_stuffed_possums (Psych (TV 2006))
13. alchemy by withoutwords (Psych (TV 2006))
14. Little Murder in the Big Woods (Psych (TV 2006))
15. A Trail of Deduction by aswarmofbisexualbees (Hannibal (TV), Psych (TV 2006))
16. better off as lovers (in the night-time) by comma_to_the_top (Psych (TV 2006))
17. Lassie, don’t be a skeptic in a haunted house! by Storyofourdays (Psych (TV 2006))
18. what if it is by withoutwords (Psych (TV 2006))
19. Love the Trouble by szucsf (Psych (TV 2006))
20. A Conversation With Mr. Yin by the_northwind (Psych (TV 2006))