Fics like One Night but Two Times that Night

Set during episode 302 after the masquerade party, Rebecca and Nathaniel have sex for the first time. This story explores why Nathaniel thought it would be more than a one night stand, and what was the thing Nathaniel wanted to do to her that night.

You may also like

the space your name makes by anthropologicalhands (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))
no desire to suffer twice (in reality and in retrospect) by notbang (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))
thoughts of you subside, then i get another letter by cori_the_bloody, notbang (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))
Who Needs A Date When You've Got A Heather? by burglebezzlement (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))
Rebecca and Nathaniel Give Love a Chance by heartbash (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))
a curious, wanting thing by softnow (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))
you're the fire and the flood by notbang (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))
Panem with Parents: The Question by TabbyCatLibrarian (Hunger Games Series - All Media Types, Hunger Games Trilogy - Suzanne Collins, more)
Bite-Size Love by heartbash (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))
Supply Shopping and Tree Climbing by justwantedtodance (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))
you're gonna catch heaven when i get home by softnow (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))
that silly girl, she's all wound up by cori_the_bloody (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))
ten steps ahead (don't leave me behind) by FeoplePeel (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))
don't know what i've done (or if i like what i've begun) by notbang (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))
don't know what you're carrying or how your heart is wired by notbang (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))
dared you to kiss me and ran when you tried by ghostmaggie (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))
it’s obvious that my heart beats for you by ghostmaggie (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))
White Josh Kissed Me! (And I Don't Know What That Means!) by scullyseviltwin (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))
the landing light by eyesontheskyline (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV))
Blame It On The Alcohol by yumytaffy (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend (TV), Parks and Recreation)