Fics like Confidence Man

Colin Shea is a goddamn gift. Or: five times Colin reminds Ally how awesome she is just by being himself, and one time Ally reminds Colin that that's exactly what love is.

You may also like

1. better than our first kiss, snow falling at Christmas by cashewdani (What's Your Number? (2011))
2. Miss “No Way, It’s All Good” by gwyneth%20rhys (What's Your Number? (2011))
3. Someone Like You by sunsetmog (What's Your Number? (2011))
4. be the change by torigates (What's Your Number? (2011))
5. More Than A Little True by copperbadge (What's Your Number? (2011))
6. and you know you're going to fall by Merideath, katertots (Thor (Movies), What's Your Number? (2011))
7. Crushed by theimaginesyouneveraskedfor (What's Your Number? (2011), The Night Manager (TV))
8. Every Other Weekend by georgiapeach30513 (Red One (2023), Chris Evans - Fandom, more)
9. The Perks of Being the Best Friend by MimiWritesHerFandoms (What's Your Number? (2011))
10. I'll Tumblr 4 Ya by katertots (Captain America (Movies), Thor (Movies), more)
11. You Can Have the Town, Why Don’t You Take It by gwyneth%20rhys (What's Your Number? (2011))
12. if all my mistakes (led me to you) by bitelikefire (Captain America - All Media Types, What's Your Number? (2011))
13. Baby, I'm On Fire by Rhiannon_A_Christy (Thor (Movies), What's Your Number? (2011))
14. Just a Number by Flora (What's Your Number? (2011))
15. Secret Admirer by cametobuyplums (What's Your Number? (2011))
16. nothing to keep us apart by legete (What's Your Number? (2011))
17. Doppelgangers by usa123 (The Avengers (Marvel Movies), Marvel Cinematic Universe, more)
18. Desperate Affairs by georgiapeach30513 (Defending Jacob (TV 2020), Knives Out (2019), more)
19. And You Tell Me You're Sorry (But You're Not) by misura (What's Your Number? (2011))
20. An Unexpected Gain by TwittyTelly (What's Your Number? (2011), Marvel Cinematic Universe, more)