Fics like The Secrets That You Keep

Sam and Dean pose as a married couple to investigate the deaths of three couples who all went to the same marriage counselor. Business as usual, nothing to see here, all the lies and denial and Dean being kind of an ass sometimes. Nothing out of the ordinary.

You may also like

1. With Your Dreams Untold by waywardelle (Supernatural)
2. Running With Scissors by dreamlittleyo (Supernatural)
3. For Keeps For Good Forever by candle_beck (Supernatural)
4. Bedtime by Marie_Tomas (Supernatural)
5. Blow Me by rockstarpeach (Supernatural)
6. Bullet for my Valentine by merle_p (Supernatural)
7. The Time Sam Winchester Mistakenly Thought he was Harboring the Antichrist by ObsidianRomance (Supernatural)
8. A Key to Every Door by dreamlittleyo, rivers_bend (Supernatural)
9. Waiting Games by Nutkin (Supernatural)
10. Manhattan for Beads by candle_beck (Supernatural)
11. Free and Clear by Mollyamory (Supernatural)
12. Going My Way by orphan_account (Supernatural)
13. It's Happening Today, Valentine, Valentine by MothQQueen (Supernatural)
14. Rabbit Hole by doctor__idiot (Supernatural)
15. You Shine On, Boys by archea2 (Supernatural, The Shining (1980))
16. I know all the rules (and then I know how to break ‘em) by cherryvanilla (Supernatural)
17. Sam in the Fog by orphan_account (Supernatural)
18. Salt Water Cure by smalltrolven (Supernatural)
19. The Past (It's a New Generation) by firstlovelatespring (Supernatural)
20. By Your Command by Wincesteriffic%20Kaz (Supernatural)